Pulpit

Correcting Orson Pratt's Doctrine of the Godhead—The Removal of Amasa Lyman from the Quorum of the Twelve

Brigham Young, President of the Church

1867 October General Conference·Monday Morning Session·1867-10-07

We are happy in the contemplation that the ladies' bonnets will not get wet to day in the bowery we are safe here3 I have a few remarks to make before we close our meeting I will say that I am well satisfied with the remarks of Professor Pratt on the subject that he has dwelt upon mostly this morning with very few exceptions perhaps I might say one and that is this when a man gets up to declare what the Latter-day Saints believe in he ought to be pretty sure that they do believe it when I get up before the people I tell them what I believe and they may do what they please I do not tell the community what the Latter-day Saints believe for they may believe a thousand things I do not Brother Pratt says to all the world in his [things?] the Latter- day Saints believe thus and so I never took this liberty in my life I can tell the Latter-day Saints what they should believe whether they do or not this it is another thing in this I am disposed to correct Brother Pratt and hope I will never hear it again in his preachings [in regards?] the subject that he has been dwelling upon this morning that is the Deity our Father and our God [he] does very well but I will ask the Latter-day Saints of Israel that have read his writings if they have not been led in a swamp and they can not get out if they followed him in the [illegible]4 spirit of his [two or three words crossed out] I made a statement 6 months ago at our conference I brought up the subject of people wandering from the path of truth relating to the conference in my view how it was that the ancient church left the oracles of God one received this idea and another received another idea and they wandered off and separated departed neglected this that and the other until they sacrificed the commandments and ordinances of house of God but in my explanation I observed it is easy for men and good men to depart from the path of truth and mentioned 3 individuals one was Brother Orson Pratt preaching that God was attributes and nothing else shall I declare to you he has declared it to me that there was no God but attributes and we have plenty of brethren [illegible] the same whether they say so or not and I put this question to him [for a source?] I ask Brother Pratt whether he by his philosophy could show that ever an attribute was ever exhibited through a tabernacle or personage he could not answer the question and he has reflected and now since came from his mission ever believed in his doctrine and I have no idea ever did but vain speculations vain philosophy and his position is correct with the gospel Latter-day Saints believe in he do not know what they believe in but he can tell what he believes and I take this

as you heard yesterday what was said with regard to the resurrection open confession good for the soul when the elders of Israel raise their hands in capacity of the conference to sustain an individual to direct them in the ways of life and salvation and get up speculative ideas and undertake to sustain them they will find themselves in swamp and they will [illegible] themselves and we shall be under the necessity of presenting one man to dismiss from the Quorum of the 12 [after/for?] however for that is Brother Amasa Lyman Lyman5 Brother Pratt I expect will take this with quite good feelings as I take his honesty and good sincerity as for his belief [about?] the spirit of Christ that God was a mere object of attributes never believed such doctrine he said he did but he bewildered himself as his writings lost the elders I leave it to any man ever read them to see whether or not in the light and swamp I say I am satisfied with Orson's Pratt's position if he stick to it and not get up speculative ideas and lead off and see who will follow him for I tell him not a saint on this earth or heavens ever battle him in his vain speculative ideas unless they have [of/the?] within them a cry [and the?] soul of man to preach to save the people the saints will not hear anybody else the doctrine that Brother Pratt has been preaching he went [way further?] into things we know nothing about while in the field I am satisfied to take the scriptures as they read [for/if?] the Lord did create man after his own image male and female I am willing to say he did and let that suffice and [if?] Jesus did say whoever has seen him has seen the Father I am willing to let that remain a fact the very express image of his Father and he looked so much like the Son of Man that did not know him thought he was a man walking through the crowd same as any other man and if he was here to day in presence as was in his he stood here and heard the preaching and go out of tabernacle and no person think to know difference to a stranger’s. I say that he [illegible] a spirit without body parts passions anything of the kind well to say he is God our Father and if we do his will by and by we see him embrace [him] and he us and we rejoice together and have a time of rejoicing such as never had our hearts glad to get into this tabernacle when we return home see and understand we have been faithful to our mission the joy that can fill our hearts cannot be expressed by any mortal being God bless you.

Cite this talkBrigham Young, "Correcting Orson Pratt's Doctrine of the Godhead—The Removal of Amasa Lyman from the Quorum of the Twelve," 1867 October General Conference, Monday Morning Session (1867-10-07). Pulpit Vault, 1867-10-07-young-correcting-orson-pratt-on-the-godhead. Contemporaneous report text from catalog.churchofjesuschrist.org.Pulpit Vault, edition of 14 November 2026 (commit d84338bd3e).