No Opposition to the Priesthood—Twice Voting Against Joseph Smith in Nauvoo over Hogs and Dogs
Brigham Young · · 1868-02-14
Fidelity
Sole surviving witness (of two parallel scholarly transcriptions of the same shorthand pages; see research_note): LaJean Purcell Carruth's scholarly transcription of George D. Watt's original Pitman shorthand report of a School of the Prophets meeting, Papers of George D. Watt MS 4534 box 5 disk 4 images 82-90, Church History Library, CR 100 912 inventory item cr-100-912-0299; transcribed by Carruth 28 June 2011. Neither this address nor the meeting was printed in the Journal of Discourses or in CR 100 317. This is the fourth and closing address Brigham Young gave in the meeting, delivered after Heber C. Kimball's second speech (transcribed in full in this same manuscript item but belonging to Kimball, not part of this talk); it begins verbatim at the speaker label 'President Young' and runs to the close of the meeting, 'I do not care why they are,' after which the record notes the singing of 'How Firm a Foundation' and dismissal by Elder Orson Hyde (both excluded here as meeting minutes). The body is Carruth's transcription verbatim, retaining her bracketed uncertain and illegible readings (among them [impartially?], [ng/neglecting?], [kb/keep?], [and got/to get?], [illegible], [By/Wy?], [Waterson?], [union looking?], [assay/-s-?]), and the wide word gaps that mark gaps in the shorthand. Carruth's footnote markers 4, 5, and 6 fall inside this address and are retained where the transcription carries them: footnote 4 ('Character is extremely faint, may be wiped out') marks the bracketed reading [--?] after 'I did not do it'; footnote 5 ('Apparently others spoke, which Watt did not record') marks the repeated speaker label 'President Young5'; footnote 6 ('Word written over') marks 'I swear by the Gods in6.' The three preceding addresses of this meeting are authored separately as 1868-02-14-young-account-of-the-visit-to-provo, 1868-02-14-young-political-offices-subject-to-the-priesthood, and 1868-02-14-young-ashamed-and-disgusted.
Witnesses
Carruth CR 100 912 inventory item cr-100-912-0299. Scholarly re-transcription of George D. Watt's original Pitman shorthand report, Papers of George D. Watt MS 4534 box 5 disk 4 images 82-90, Church History Library. Not printed in Journal of Discourses or CR 100 317. Transcribed by LaJean Purcell Carruth 28 June 2011. The item is a composite record of the full meeting, including remarks by Wilford Woodruff, George Q. Cannon, Heber C. Kimball, and a roll-call of named witnesses, each excluded from or authored separately from this talk.
Carruth CR 100 912 inventory item cr-100-912-0721. Independent scholarly transcription of the same shorthand pages, Papers of George D. Watt MS 4534 box 5 disk 4 image 88, transcribed by Carruth 9 February 2012. Catalogued under Heber C. Kimball's name because it transcribes his second speech in full, but the Brigham Young portion beginning 'Now [impartially?] deliberately look at this little item' duplicates this talk's text; not used as the preferred witness because item cr-100-912-0299 is the primary catalogued record of the full meeting.
Collation history
Ingested; not yet independently reviewed.
Corrections
This is a living critical edition. If you find a transcription, metadata, or sourcing error in this talk, report it to the editors →Reports are collated against the page scan and land as corrections in the vault.