Pulpit
Textual record

Blessings the Saints Fail to Receive—Written Revelation Among Us—On the Sons of Joseph Smith and the New Reorganization

Brigham Young · · 1860-11-04

Fidelity

◑Contemporaneous report

Sole surviving witness, and incomplete: the extant shorthand is only part of a discourse, per the notebook's own contents page (part of a discourse by Brother Brigham Young), and an asterisk at the top of the manuscript page marks it as continued from an earlier booklet that is not extant, so the opening of the sermon is lost. The extant text ends mid-discourse, marked in the manuscript End of extant shorthand for this sermon. Reported in Pitman shorthand by George D. Watt; Papers of George D. Watt, MS 4534, box 3, disk 2, 1860, images 1-6. Transcribed from Watt's shorthand by LaJean Purcell Carruth 10 December 2010, revised 3 November 2014. This sermon was never printed in the Journal of Discourses and is not in CR 100 317, so no printed text exists to collate against. The body is verbatim from Carruth's transcription, including her wide word gaps (marking gaps in the shorthand), her bracketed uncertain readings, the asterisk that opens the extant text in the manuscript, and the unpunctuated run-on syntax of the shorthand record. Carruth's editorial bracketed note identifying the manuscript context (part of a discourse ... continued from elsewhere ... not extant) and her closing bracketed note (end of extant shorthand for this sermon) are both editorial framing rather than transcribed speech and are excluded from the body. Carruth's own topical header for the sermon, excluded from the body, reads (in part): FROG TOWN AND CAMP FLOYD ARE HELL; ON SONS OF JOSEPH SMITH [AT LENGTH]; STRONG CONDEMNATION OF EMMA; JOSEPH'S SONS WILL NEVER LEAD THE LDS CHURCH; THEY DENY THE PLURALITY OF WOMEN AND OTHER TEACHINGS OF THEIR FATHER; MENTIONS NEW CHURCH [REORGANIZED CHURCH]. A single editorial footnote marker (1) falls inside the body, attached to little Joseph Smith, glossing it as Joseph Smith III; per the pagination of the source PDF, the footnote's own text appears on the manuscript page rather than at the true end of the document, so it is summarized here rather than left inline, and only the superscript marker remains in the body.

Witnesses

Carruth CR 100 912 inventory item cr-100-912-0130. Scholarly transcription of George D. Watt's original Pitman shorthand report, catalogued at the Church History Library. Papers of George D. Watt MS 4534 box 3 disk 2 1860 images 1-6. Sermon not in Journal of Discourses or CR 100 317. Transcribed by LaJean Purcell Carruth 10 December 2010, revised 3 November 2014. Sole surviving witness of this sermon fragment; the opening is lost (continued from a non-extant earlier booklet) and the extant shorthand ends mid-discourse.

Collation history

Ingested; not yet independently reviewed.

Corrections

This is a living critical edition. If you find a transcription, metadata, or sourcing error in this talk, report it to the editors →Reports are collated against the page scan and land as corrections in the vault.